• Tentang UGM
  • Portal Akademik
  • Pusat TI
  • Perpustakaan
  • Penelitian
Universitas Gadjah Mada
  • About Us
    • About CRCS
    • Vision & Mission
    • People
      • Faculty Members and Lecturers
      • Staff Members
      • Students
      • Alumni
    • Facilities
    • Library
  • Master’s Program
    • Overview
    • Curriculum
    • Courses
    • Schedule
    • Admission
    • Scholarship
    • Accreditation and Certification
    • Academic Collaborations
      • Crossculture Religious Studies Summer School
      • Florida International University
    • Academic Documents
    • Student Satisfaction Survey
  • Article
    • Perspective
    • Book Review
    • Event Report
    • Class Journal
    • Interview
    • Wed Forum Report
    • Thesis Review
    • News
  • Publication
    • Reports
    • Books
    • Newsletter
    • Monthly Update
    • Infographic
  • Research
    • CRCS Researchs
    • Resource Center
  • Community Engagement
    • Film
      • Indonesian Pluralities
      • Our Land is the Sea
    • Wednesday Forum
    • ICIR
    • Amerta Movement
  • Beranda
  • Articles
  • The Violent Verses of the Qur’an in Comparison between the Classical and Modern Interpretations

The Violent Verses of the Qur’an in Comparison between the Classical and Modern Interpretations

  • Articles, Berita, Headline, News
  • 4 April 2016, 11.27
  • Oleh:
  • 1

Aziz Anwar Fachrudin | CRCS | Article
Al-Qur'anAmong the challenges Muslims face when they are engaged in the recently overwhelming debate on whether Islam is a religion of violence/peace is the fact that the Quran contains many verses which, at least when seen at a glance, promote violence. Indeed, there are verses in the Quran that even encourage fighting and killing, addressed to those considered unbelievers/infidels (kuffar) and/or polytheists (mushrikin); and when they are read and interpreted literally, they can be seen as preaching hatred toward non-Muslims. Moreover, some of those verses have been picked by the Islamic State (of Iraq and al-Sham, or ISIS) to justify its atrocities toward those having different beliefs. On the other hand, those “violent verses” are often cited by many involved in the debate, particularly by Islamophobias in the West, to discredit Islam and to show that Islam is a religion of violence, instead of peace.
This paper is going to examine those “violent verses’; not all, but some of them that have similar redaction. That is, those verses which read, more or less, “kill them wherever you find them”. There are three verses which are like that: (1) QS. al-Baqarah [2]:191; (2) QS. al-Nisa’ [4]:89; and (3) QS. al-Tawbah [9]:5. It is to examine both the classical and the modern interpretations of those three verses. By classical interpretations I mean the interpretations and commentaries of those verses as in classical books of tafsir written by medieval, pre-modern Muslim scholars of exegesis, to which very often many Muslims today still refer. By modern interpretations I mean the interpretations and commentaries that are written by modern Muslim exegetes. Along this line of elaboration, I shall compare both in order to know to what extent there has been a change in interpretations of the abovementioned verses.
This paper shall therefore be intended to convey three things. First is to show both classical and modern interpretations of those verses. Second is to point out what we will get when we compare those two types of interpretations and how the verses have been interpreted differently. Third, this paper shall be finished by some hermeneutical reflections resulting from the examination of both the classical and the modern interpretations. As for the classical interpretations, the books of tafsir that shall be mostly referred to in this paper are that of al-Tabari (839-923), Al-Razi (1149-1209), al-Qurtubi (1214-1273), and Ibn Kathir (1301-1373). While for the modern interpretations, the books of tafsir that shall be referred to are that of Rashid Rida (1865-1935), al-Sha‘rawi (1911-1998), Al-Zuhayli (1932-2015), and Quraish Shihab (1944-…). All these books of tafsir contains exegeses that are elaborated in chronological, chapter-based way, or verse by verse conforming to the way the verses are serially organized in the Quran. (This way is technically known as al-tafsir al-tajzi‘i or tafsir based on chapters or partitions of the Quran, as compared to al-tafsir al-mawdu‘i or tafsir based on themes/topics.) In this paper, when I mention a name of a mufassir (exegete) of them, it means I refer to his interpretations/commentaries that come after the verse being discussed. Read more in religio.uinsby.ac.id
*Aziz Anwar Fachrudin is CRCS Student batch 2014
 

Tags: al-Qurtubi Al-Razi al-Sha‘rawi al-Tabari al-tafsir al-mawdu‘i al-tafsir al-tajzi‘i Al-Zuhayli CRCS CRCS-UGM Ibn Kathir infidels Islamophobias kuffar mushrikin Muslims polytheists Qur’an Rashid Rida tafsir UGM. violent verses

Leave A Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Comment (1)

  1. Aiden 1 years ago

    Lord Jesus bless you all! Come to know the truth that the Lord has risen from the dead!

    Reply

Instagram

What happens when religious identities refuse to f What happens when religious identities refuse to fit neatly into sectarian labels? This forum explores how Shiʿi histories are constructed, remembered, and contested across Southeast Asia and beyond. Through fragmented evidence, shifting allegiances, and local knowledge traditions, it asks who gets to define religious belonging—and whose histories get recognized, obscured, or forgotten.

Come and join this thought-provoking discussion with @sarahmuwahidah at #wednesdayforum.
We provide snacks and drinks, don't forget to bring your tumbler. This event is free and open to public.
SADAR Salib berdiri, saf salat merapat. Sebuah po SADAR 
Salib berdiri, saf salat merapat. Sebuah potret kebersamaan yang mengingatkan bahwa perbedaan keyakinan tidak harus menjadi penghalang untuk berjalan bersama. Ketika demonstrasi usai, ujian lain pun dimulai: apakah kita tetap berdiri di sisi mereka yang tertindas, bahkan ketika mereka berbeda keyakinan?

simak tulisan @angelique_tjoa tentang #indonesiasadar hanya di situs web crcs
SABDA-ABDI Bunyinya berdekatan, tetapi jarak kuas SABDA-ABDI

Bunyinya berdekatan, tetapi jarak kuasanya bisa sejauh langit dan bumi. Sabda datang dari atas, abdi belajar mendengarkan dari bawah. Yang satu terbiasa dituruti, yang lain diharapkan berbakti. Namun, apa jadinya ketika abdi mulai bersabda? Apakah gusti masih bersedia mendengar, atau telinga istana hanya terbuka untuk pujian? Barangkali, yang perlu diuji bukan kesetiaan abdi, melainkan kebesaran seorang gusti: sanggupkah ia menerima suara yang tak lagi terdengar seperti sembah?

baca gerundelan aelengkapnya di situs web crcs
Can the body speak where words fall short? Throug Can the body speak where words fall short?

Through Amerta Movement, dialogue moves beyond words into movement, embodiment, and sensory awareness. Dance becomes a way of listening, relating, and connecting—with ourselves, others, and the world around us.

Join us in reimagining dialogue with @samsulmaarif6202 at #wednesdayforum.

We provide snacks and drinks, don't forget to bring your tumbler. This event is free and open to public.
Follow on Instagram

Twitter

Tweets by crcsugm

Universitas Gadjah Mada

Gedung Sekolah Pascasarjana UGM, 3rd Floor
Jl. Teknika Utara, Pogung, Yogyakarta, 55284
Email address: crcs@ugm.ac.id

 

© CRCS - Universitas Gadjah Mada

KEBIJAKAN PRIVASI/PRIVACY POLICY